This Supreme Pizza Grilled Cheese Sandwich is everything that you want on a pizza in grilled cheese form! It’s the ultimate pizza sandwich recipe!
Growing up we had a bowl of soup and a grilled cheese sandwich at least once a week. As a mom now, I get that it was a cheap meal. Because of the frequency of this meal, it became something I have fond memories of now. I love making grilled cheese sandwiches for my girls, even though we don’t have them as often as I did growing up.
After we created a peanut butter and jelly grilled cheese, Andrew and I had an idea to create a series about gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches. This pizza grilled cheese is the first in a series of gourmet grilled cheese sandwiches we’ll be doing and we guarantee that by the end of the week, you’ll discover one of the best grilled cheese sandwiches you’ve ever had.
How to Make a Supreme Pizza Grilled Cheese
This pizza grilled cheese sandwich has all of your favorite supreme pizza toppings. There’s sausage, pepperoni, and ham for meats. Then, for toppings, we included red onions, 5 types of peppers, spinach and mushrooms. Of course, there’s cheddar and mozzarella cheese, as well as marinara sauce.
We start by buttering up two skinny sandwich rounds and browning them in a skillet. Next, we layer all our ingredients and then put the grilled cheese in the oven until the cheese is melted. It cooks up beautifully and is so much fun.
The reason we cook the pizza grilled cheese in the oven versus all on the stove is because of the amount of ingredients. It would be hard to get them all warm in a skillet before the bread burns, even when cooking on a low setting, so grilled cheese in the oven is the best option.
What sides to serve with a pizza grilled cheese sandwich?
This is a large sandwich by itself, but we know you’d love some side dish ideas for this grilled cheese recipe.
- Homemade French Fries (Try dipping them in our Honey Mustard BBQ Sauce)
- Caprese Pasta Salad
- Garlic Parmesan Wings
- Sweet Potato and Kohlrabi Fries (with a Spicy Roasted Red Pepper Mayo Dip)
- Tomato Cucumber Avocado Salad
Any of these will pair perfectly with this pizza grilled cheese sandwich!
Pizza Grilled Cheese Recipe
This Supreme Pizza Grilled Cheese Sandwich is everything that you want on a pizza in grilled cheese form! It's the ultimate pizza sandwich recipe!
- 1 tbsp unsalted butter
- 4 skinny sandwhich rounds
- 1 italian sausage, cooked
- 2 oz pepperoni, sliced thick or thin
- 1/8 cup spinach
- 1/8 cup mushroom slices
- 1/4 red pepper, sliced into two rounds
- 1/4 green pepper, sliced into two rounds
- 1/4 yellow pepper, sliced into two rounds
- 1/4 orange pepper, sliced into two rounds
- 1/8 cup banana peppers
- 4 slices Mozzarella cheese
- 4 slices Cheddar cheese
Preheat oven to 250 degrees
Cut cooked sausage in half lengthwise and then in half again. Set aside.
Spread butter on one side of each of the skinny sandwich rounds.
Heat a skillet over medium and brown the sandwich rounds butter side down until a golden brown is reached (2-3 minutes). Remove from here
On the none buttered side, layer all your ingredients.
Repeat with remaining sandwich.
Place both sandwiches on an oven safe baking sheet and cook for 7-10 minutes or until cheese has completely melted and ingredients are warmed.
Remove and serve.
*This recipe uses raw peppers and mushrooms for the sandwich, feel free to cook before hand if desired.
*Nutritional values are estimates. Please double check your own products before using.
Pin this Supreme Pizza Grilled Cheese for later!